Freedom and Weakness of Will

نویسنده

  • Paul Hoffman
چکیده

Can absolute freedom of will be defended by arguing that apparent cases of diminished freedom when we act out of passion are cases of weakness of will? Rogers Albritton thought so. What is intriguing about Albritton’s view is that he thought when we act from desire we are making choices, yet our desires are not functioning as reasons for those choices. So our desires must be influencing our choices in some other unspecified way that does not diminish our freedom. I challenge the coherence of this position. My strategy is to examine the views of leading theorists of the will – Descartes, Aquinas and Reid – to argue that the only clear way in which passions can influence our choices so that we can accurately be described as weak-willed and yet nevertheless free is that our passions influence our choices by providing reasons for them. In defending what he took to be Descartes’s view that we have absolute freedom of will, Rogers Albritton in his 1985 APA Presidential Address seemed to suggest that the most troubling sorts of cases for him are those in which our behavior is ‘from desire, out of fear, on impulse and so on.’ In other words, what Descartes called the passions of the soul are what Albritton took to be the biggest threat to the thesis that we have absolute freedom of will. How could our will remain absolutely free when we act out of fear? Albritton’s first step in defending the view that even the passions do not diminish the will’s absolute freedom was to distinguish between acting from one’s desires and acting in view of one’s desires. When we act in view of one of our passions, the passion is playing the role of providing us with a reason for acting in the same way someone else’s desires might give us a reason for acting. Albritton argued that since reasons don’t have the power 1 See Rogers Albritton, ‘Freedom of the Will and Freedom of Action’, Proceedings and Addresses of the American Philosophical Association, 59 (1985) p. 248: ‘I don’t see unfreedom of will even in this most promising part of the forest.’ 2 Ibid. © 2008 The Author Journal compilation © 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd Ratio (new series) XXI 1 March 2008 0034–0006 to diminish our freedom of will, when we act in view of one of our passions our freedom of will is not diminished. But he thought it is rare that passions are playing only the role of providing reasons for action. Usually when passions play a role in our behavior, we are acting from passion. What happens when we act from passion? One possibility Albritton considered is that we are not really acting at all. Acting from passion is like a seizure or like being thrown violently into bed or being chained up. The idea here, as I understand it, is that the will is bypassed. We aren’t making a choice. But Albritton apparently believed that this possibility does not explain all or even perhaps most of the instances when we act from passion. He seemed to think instead that in most cases, or at least in the cases most troubling for the thesis that we have absolute freedom of will, when we act from passion we are making a choice. The passion is not bypassing the will but rather, and this is my language not his, operating through the will. After introducing the notion of acting ‘from desire, out of fear, on impulse, and so on’ and mentioning the possibility that such cases are like seizures in which we are not acting, Albritton proceeded to consider cases, focusing primarily on alcoholism, that he said were neither like seizures nor fully automatic. So these are cases in which the will is not bypassed, yet also apparently cases in which the agent is not acting merely in view of her desire. Albritton did not explicitly state that the three cases he mentioned – addiction, alcoholism, and child molesting – are cases of acting from passion, but the flow of the discussion strongly suggests that he thought they were. However, even if he would have denied that addiction, alcoholism, and child molesting are cases of acting from passion, the main point is that he thought they are cases in 3 Ibid., pp. 246–248. 4 Ibid., p. 248: ‘Acting from desire is quite another and commoner thing. Indeed pure cases of acting in consideration of a (felt) desire must be rare at best.’ 5 Ibid. 6 This is something I had misunderstood before. I claimed in ‘Strength and Freedom of Will: Descartes and Albritton’, Philosophical Studies, 77 (1995), pp. 249–250, that Albritton thought all cases of acting from passion were cases in which choice is bypasssed. 7 Albritton, p. 249. 8 My earlier failure to recognize that Albritton thought that when we act from passion we are often making a choice was based on my failure to see that his discussion of alcoholism is a continuation of his discussion of acting from passion. I thought before that he was bringing up the cases of addiction, alcoholism, and child molesting as a different set of cases. FREEDOM AND WEAKNESS OF WILL 43

برای دانلود متن کامل این مقاله و بیش از 32 میلیون مقاله دیگر ابتدا ثبت نام کنید

ثبت نام

اگر عضو سایت هستید لطفا وارد حساب کاربری خود شوید

منابع مشابه

بررسی تحلیلی مبانی، اصول و روش‌های تربیت سیاسی از منظر امام علی(ع) در نهج‌البلاغه

 This is an analytical and descriptive study of Imam Ali's views about the basic methods and principles of political education in Nahjolbalaghe. The nine basics are as followings: devotion to God, moderation, civilization, environment influences, contemplation, benevolence, freedom and free will, weakness, and, last but not least, the attraction of benefaction.With regard to the first basic met...

متن کامل

Is the Contemporary Account of Weakness of Will Complete?

Before an outstanding article in 1999 by Richard Holton, weakness of will was identified as an agent's action contrary to his or her better judgment, while other better choices are available. The contemporary account of weakness of will (i.e., Holton’s theory) explains it in terms of intention. Accordingly, weakness of will happens if an agent fails to stick to his or her previously formed inte...

متن کامل

Human Freedom and Moral Responsibility In The Light of Theistic Beliefs

Theistic and atheistic beliefs respectively play a fundamental role in the definition of man's free will and moral responsibility, so far as they can determine the nature, quality, and quantity of human's freedom. After believing in God, the belief in a revealed or a non-revealed religion and the manner in which God’s attributes are interpreted play an essential role in the definition of free w...

متن کامل

Will Universal Health Coverage (UHC) Lead to the Freedom to Lead Flourishing and Healthy Lives?; Comment on “Inequities in the Freedom to Lead a Flourishing and Healthy Life: Issues for Healthy Public Policy”

The focus on public policy and health equity is discussed in reference to the current global health policy discussion on Universal Health Coverage (UHC). This initiative has strong commitment from the leadership of the international organizations involved, but a lack of policy clarity outside of the health financing component may limit the initiative’s impact on health inequity. In order to add...

متن کامل

اصل آزادی به منزله یک حق و ظهور جریان های فکری در اندیشه سیاسی اسلام

This article discusses freedom the most important issue in political philosophy and the ideals of mankind. Freedom can be taken in two meaning: A: freedom as a reality and B: freedom as a right.What is debatable in political philosophy and law, freedom is regarded as a right. The disagreement concerning the definition among philosophers is due to three reasons: concept verbal commonality, ident...

متن کامل

Who’s Responsible for Teacher Training? Ministry of Education, or Higher Education?

This qualitative study aimed to compare the qualification of Higher Education system and Education system in field of teacher education. Using qualitative content analysis, with open coding data by interviews and open-ended questionnaire, data been coded and categorized and then analyzed. Participants of research were selected by purposive sampling (22 samples). Through participants opinions fo...

متن کامل

ذخیره در منابع من


  با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید

برای دانلود متن کامل این مقاله و بیش از 32 میلیون مقاله دیگر ابتدا ثبت نام کنید

ثبت نام

اگر عضو سایت هستید لطفا وارد حساب کاربری خود شوید

عنوان ژورنال:

دوره   شماره 

صفحات  -

تاریخ انتشار 2008